Vitalik Buterin Flips to 'Total Bull' on leanPCS as Ethereum Eyes Quantum-Safe Future
Vitalik Buterin says he is now a 'total bull' on leanPCS, a signature-aggregation route in draft EIP-8288 that could cut Ethereum's post-quantum costs.
By Shitij GuptaResearcher

Vitalik Buterin said he has gone from thinking leanPCS was "total bull" to being "a total bull" on the approach, in a post on X on 16 November 2026. The Ethereum co-founder's reversal covers one of three routes in a draft proposal he co-authored for handling the far larger signatures that quantum-resistant cryptography brings.
That draft is EIP-8288, "In-mempool signature and proof aggregation", created on 3 June 2026 with Thomas Coratger, who has led the Ethereum Foundation's Post-Quantum Security team since January 2026. Its problem is arithmetic: a standard Ethereum signature is 65 bytes, while the quantum-resistant alternatives under discussion run from about 1,000 to 6,000 bytes.
- The news: Vitalik Buterin said on X on 16 November 2026 that he now favours leanPCS, one of three routes in draft EIP-8288 for handling the larger signatures post-quantum security requires.
- The key figure: The EIP puts current hash-based quantum-resistant signatures at roughly 2-3 kB and 150,000 to 200,000 gas to verify, against 65 bytes for a standard Ethereum signature.
- What happens next: EIP-8288 remains a draft with its reference implementation listed as unfinished, and no launch or activation date has been announced.
What EIP-8288 Does With a Signature
The proposal lets transactions carry lightweight dependency triples, listed as (scheme, data_hash, verification_key_hash), which are aggregated off-chain into a single recursive STARK. Block validity then requires that one recursive STARK rather than each signature on its own, which the EIP calls efficient post-quantum and scalable signature aggregation using Lean Ethereum tooling.
Without it, the EIP says the cost of quantum-resistant signatures and proofs would make privacy protocols impractically expensive and incompatible with FOCIL (EIP-7805) and Frame Transactions (EIP-8141), two other proposals in Ethereum's pipeline.
The Numbers Behind the Size Problem
Current hash-based quantum-resistant signatures cost about 2-3 kB and 150,000 to 200,000 gas to verify, the EIP says. Hash-based zero-knowledge STARKs are heavier: over 128 kB, or as much as 512 kB when fast generation is the goal.
For scale, Buterin's explainer puts a standard Ethereum signature at 65 bytes and quantum-safe signatures at 1 to 6 kilobytes, with zero-knowledge proofs growing from a few hundred bytes to roughly 128 kilobytes. Research shared on the Ethereum Research forum in June showed a standards-aligned quantum-safe signature from the SPHINCS family can be verified with no protocol change at about 150,000 gas, against roughly 3,000 gas for an ECDSA signature.
Buterin estimated that dedicated PCS verification could let STARKs be checked through the Ethereum Virtual Machine for about 20,000 to 40,000 gas, a technical estimate rather than a settled gas schedule.
leanPCS, leanSTARK and What Each Costs
EIP-8288 lays out three approaches. leanSPHINCS is the most specialized. leanSTARK would support any signature scheme, privacy protocols and hidden multisignature logic, but Ethereum would first need to agree on a programming language for users' programs beyond the EVM, which Buterin said would likely take time. leanPCS sits between the two.
"LeanPCS gives you the same generality as leanSTARK, in a way that could potentially be implemented very quickly," Buterin wrote.
He said leanSTARK could be added later, and described the direction as a route toward a "cryptographic proof singularity" sooner than developers had expected.
The Quantum Clock, and What Is Not Settled
Google Quantum AI research published in March 2026 estimated that breaking 256-bit elliptic curve cryptography, the type Ethereum uses for account signatures, could require roughly 1,200 logical qubits. NIST anticipates deprecating ECDSA by 2030 and disallowing it by 2035, per Ethereum.org's post-quantum roadmap, which also states that no quantum computer today can break Ethereum's cryptography and that the work is preparation, not a response to an active threat.
The Foundation's post-quantum team says a sufficiently powerful quantum computer could recover private keys from exposed public keys, allowing forged signatures that could authorize new transactions with a user's funds. NIST's ML-DSA standard specifies a digital signature system believed to resist attacks even from a large quantum computer. In February 2026 Buterin published a roadmap identifying four distinct areas of Ethereum's cryptography needing post-quantum upgrades.
The roadmap targets core post-quantum infrastructure by about 2029, with full execution-layer and ecosystem migration extending beyond that. Account abstraction is the chosen path to signature agility, specifically EIP-8141, under consideration for Hegotá in the second half of 2026. At Devcon 8 in Mumbai, Ethereum Foundation researcher Justin Drake outlined a December 2028 target for the network's post-quantum and post-AI transition, and said developer coordination rather than missing research could be the main obstacle to moving faster.
None of this makes leanPCS a live change. EIP-8288 remains a draft, its published specification still lists the reference implementation as unfinished, and Buterin's endorsement sets no launch date. leanPCS is not yet in the published specification. The proposal follows calls from researchers the previous week to prioritize quantum defenses over faster blocks in Ethereum's planned 2027 upgrade.
The next things to watch are whether the reference implementation lands and whether leanPCS is written into the spec, with EIP-8141's Hegotá slot in the second half of 2026 as the nearest dated milestone.

Shitij Gupta
Shitij Gupta is an analyst and a researcher at Altcoin Buzz. Shitij has a vast banking experience at companies such as Morgan Stanley, ETRADE and UBS. He primarily built banking and lending products, Robo Advising solutions and Mutual Fund offerings for High Net worth clients. After his stint on Wall Street, Shitij runs a family office fund and consults businesses on strategy and execution.
More from ShitijNext up

Lighter Blames Leaked API Key for Reported $15.5M Drain
Lighter blames a leaked API key, not its contracts, for the 16 November incident that halted withdrawals; researchers estimate a $15.5 million loss.
Related
More in Crypto NewsRelated
Ethereum Delays Glamsterdam Testnet Upgrade Over Smart Contract Risks

Zoom, CNN & Ledger Caught in Major Crypto Malware Attack Across 178 Sites

Bitcoin Recovers to $64,500 After $2 Billion Weekend Liquidation
